The best time to send Black Friday, Cyber Monday, and holiday emails in 2023
We sent a survey to our Shopify merchants to gather insights around their Black Friday email marketing strategy, along with Cyber Monday and the holiday season in general. When it came to their questions, a few like-minded responses repeatedly arose.
“When should I begin email marketing for the holidays?” “When is the best time to send Black Friday emails?” “How often should I be sending?” “How much is too much so I’m not annoying my subscribers?”
Each question is important to ponder. Unfortunately, there’s no black-and-white answer for any of them. The closest we can muster is “probably sooner and more often than you think.”
In this post, we’re guiding you through six different email marketing calendar strategies, any of which you can personalize to fit your needs. We’re talking through:
- Why sooner and more often may be advantageous
- Four calendar options for marketing around Black Friday/Cyber Monday (BFCM)
- Two calendar options for marketing outside of the traditional BFCM period
The case for “sooner and more” BFCM and holiday emails
One study found that 30% of consumers had already begun holiday shopping by the end of August.
This doesn't imply that mid-year — or even September — is the time to add sparkle, pop in festive photos, and launch mega deals.
Rather, recognize that there’s always a segment eager to get ahead of BFCM and check off items on the holiday shopping list. Inflation and worries around continually rising prices could enlarge that group this year. May we suggest you cater to these shoppers well before BFCM, even subtly?
We can’t predict what will happen in 2023. But throughout this post, you’ll see how holiday sales growth is slightly shifting away from BFCM and toward points earlier on the calendar.
This brings us to our second point: send more marketing emails. BFCM/holiday sales are extremely important to 45% of our survey respondents. Another 24% conveyed that they’re very important.
Therefore, increasing the regularity of email newsletter programs from your typical email frequency is critical for standing out. We see brands of all sizes boosting their send frequency during Q4. If you’re not doing it too, then you run the risk of not being noticed at all.
One word of caution: your open rates will inevitably dip, and you might lose some subscribers. It’s OK. Trends show holiday-time click and conversion rates increase.
We’re looking at holiday marketing from two angles: marketing around the BFCM period and outside of it.
The best time to send Black Friday emails and Cyber Monday promos
We’ll get to the “sooner” part shortly. But for now, let’s focus on how to add more emails to the highly critical time period of BFCM.
Keep in mind that in 2022, Cyber Monday was the biggest online shopping day of all time, as cited by Adobe. Though sales were down 1.4% year over year (as were all online sales between Thanksgiving and Cyber Monday), it remains a day of opportunity for Shopify merchants.
Food for thought: shoppers spent $12.8 million every minute on Cyber Monday 2022 during the peak hours of 11 p.m. to 12 a.m. EST.
You’ve got four strategies to consider.
1. The minimal BFCM email approach: 3-4 newsletters
I just said that you should send more frequently. Three email newsletters in addition to a regular sending cadence might not seem like much, but condense them to a two-week period, and it qualifies as a lot for many Shopify merchants.
This schedule is ideal for those who don't have much time but want to see a return on investment specifically from BFCM email marketing efforts. It’s also a good tactic when your audience doesn’t hear from you regularly, or if you struggle with low open and click rates.
Notice that I’ve pinpointed Monday as the initial best time to send out a Black Friday email. It could announce that something “big” is coming on Friday. Or, start the sale that day by providing "early access" to BFCM deals.
While I prefer Monday as the first email, it is flexible. We’ve seen Sunday a lot, or sometimes Tuesday, as the first email within the BFCM email marketing campaign. The Black Friday and Cyber Monday dates are concrete.
2. The loaded BFCM email approach: 7-10 messages
This high-volume calendar was made for Shopify brands that:
- Regularly send emails to their subscriber list
- Have stable open and click rates
Yes, it’s aggressive. And it does seem like a lot. But rest assured that many other companies are sending at this cadence during this two-week stretch.
There’s flexibility around the exact days you choose, though I suggest adhering closely to the dates I’ve pinpointed between Black Friday and Cyber Monday.
Pro tip: Don’t feel you must create a completely new email for everything you send. Reuse content by tweaking it with minor changes. Look at how Madewell approached their BFCM campaign in our Lookbook for inspiration. They used the same basic layout and images but swapped out photos/copy and changed colors.
Is your Shopify store a boutique? Consider participating in and promoting a Pink Friday sale.
Get ahead of the calendar with Seguno’s Black Friday & Cyber Monday email templates
Whether you take the minimalist approach or go all in on BFCM marketing, sometimes a marketing shortcut can make a huge difference in preserving your sanity while generating higher conversions.
Seguno’s templates are a speedy way to create Black Friday and Cyber Monday email campaigns. Made by expert designers, they include all you need to make an impact: headlines, imagery, copy, and calls to action.
All templates are customizable, too, and include placeholders for your brand product imagery.
The catalog includes:
3. The Cyber Week email approach
This email marketing calendar includes Black Friday, but is aimed more at celebrating Cyber Week as a whole. It could appeal to an audience that is more “last minute” and doesn't take advantage of other deals. This strategy is also great for remaining consistent and top of mind during a competitive season.
I recommend running a different deal each day to generate excitement and urgency. It’s a popular approach. Make sure the deal is clear and state its expiration date.
Also, define what subscribers can expect next. Well-written email subject lines can serve as a good assist in this regard. For example, a “Day 1,” “Day 2,” etc. formula signals subscribers should pay attention to their emails for the week.
There is one caveat to this approach. Monitor your unsubscribe rates. If they are .5% or higher for three consecutive sends, it’s time to scale back.
4. The Gray November email approach
In 2022, 60% of consumers began holiday shopping and browsing by early November. We’re guessing that 202will bring more of the same. Capture that interest by broadening your timeline of promos.
The idea behind this email marketing calendar is to give subscribers early access to your sale. You'll start at nearly the beginning of November and run through Thanksgiving to Cyber Monday. In ecommerce, this strategy is sometimes known as Gray November.
Ensure you offer plenty of variety in your holiday email newsletters to keep subscribers interested. Run a different promotion each week. Or, keep the promotion the same, but feature different products.
See how Brooklinen managed this approach in our BFCM Lookbook. This calendar type appeals to shoppers who like to snag sales before others. It’s potentially suitable for touting high-priced items as well.
For everything Black Friday and Cyber Monday related, visit our BFCM Marketing Hub.
Email marketing outside of BFCM
What about the bookends of holiday email marketing? Let’s look at marketing before and after the traditional BFCM crush time.
Early-bird email marketing: October
In 2022, a McKinsey study found that 56% of consumers had started holiday shopping in early October.
Shopify merchants are hearing stats like these and acting. In our survey from 2022, 17% had planned to begin promotions in early October. Another 13% were starting mid-month, and 19% were kicking things off at the end of October.
The general rule of thumb? Double your email send cadence. We recommend the calendar below if you want to jump on October promotions, which works out to about two newsletters per week.
I can think of two merchant types ideal for sending early promotions.
One is the shop that supplies the materials needed to make things. That is, shops whose audience is composed of professional crafters, or crafters-in-training who want to make a homemade gift.
Second is the store that sells luxe items. Anyone planning to buy an expensive product, such as a kitchen appliance or high-end jewelry, is probably on the lookout early.
And for all others, it can’t hurt to slip in even just one promotion. Use October as a “warming” period to build anticipation for what’s to come.
Post-Cyber Week email marketing
We’ve been beating on the drum for “sooner is better.” But our insistence on earlier emails doesn’t mean that December should be ignored.
To the contrary, make plans for when the BFCM hype fades. Remember there are always late shoppers who wait until the last minute. Others scramble to find gifts for the person who slipped their mind.
The recommended schedule below was built primarily with shipping in mind. Email frequency is heaviest toward the beginning of the month and tapers off.
Determine your shipping cutoff date and work backward when plotting email promotions, weaving the deadline into your BFCM and subsequent email marketing messages. Feel free to slide in extra emails beyond that date. Promote gift cards if you’ve got them — the perfect solution for procrastinators.
If you want to go all out, draw on the Advent-themed calendar. You could run a different promotion every day for 12 days straight, or whatever length of time you’d like.
Direct attention to your abandoned checkout email automations, too. Make sure they’re primed for attracting subscribers who found items during the BFCM sale days but haven’t been back to make the purchase.
Customize our email marketing calendars for your brand
I urge you to review these calendars and think about what works for you and your brand. Because as you can see, there’s no prescriptive best time to send Black Friday emails and the remaining holiday lot.
Maybe the right calendar is a hybrid of a few suggestions. Perhaps it’s a mix and match with an addition here, an omission there.
Customize a holiday email marketing calendar based on the needs of your business and the expectations of your subscribers. Develop a plan that you can manage and execute well and that, above all, elevates your place in the holiday shopper’s mind.
Create, manage, and track your email marketing—without leaving Shopify.
Seguno is the top-rated email solution built exclusively for Shopify. Grow your sales with high-performing newsletters, email automation campaigns, and integrations with Facebook, Instagram, banners, pop-ups and more. Build and send engaging emails in our easy-to-use editor and take email creation to the next level with our Canva integration. Automate your email marketing and drive more revenue with welcome campaigns, checkout abandonment, post-purchase automations, tag triggers and more.
Sign up for email marketing tips, resources, and industry insights to help your Shopify store grow.